Antenna Design Considerations for Underwater Applications

Key Takeaways

• Water's attenuating and dispersive nature limits signal range due to different electric permeability and conductivity than free space, requiring careful antenna design.

• Low-frequency operation is favored for large distances: ELF and VLF frequencies enable longer propagation distances and better signal penetration underwater.

• Advanced modeling and protection are vital. Using tools like FEM simulations and proper encapsulation ensures optimized antenna performance and durability in harsh underwater environments

Electromagnetic waves travel differently in water than in free space.

The underwater medium presents significant obstacles to wireless communication. Water's highly attenuating and dispersive nature limits the signal range and increases signal loss, making antenna design for underwater applications challenging. Seawater's properties, including conductivity, permittivity, and propagation characteristics, are crucial in determining antenna performance. We’ll discuss water's electromagnetic properties and provide a comprehensive overview of antenna design considerations for underwater applications.

Antenna Design Considerations for Underwater Applications

In designing antennas for underwater communication, some of the following points should be considered: 

• Understanding the Underwater Environment: The underwater medium presents significant obstacles for wireless communication. Water's highly attenuating and dispersive nature limits the signal range and increases signal loss. Seawater's properties, including conductivity, permittivity, and propagation characteristics, are crucial in determining antenna performance. An in-depth analysis of these properties is necessary to develop effective antenna designs. See the next section below for a deeper in-depth look at how water’s properties affect electromagnetic waves dictating antenna design. 

• Low-Frequency Operation: To mitigate the effects of attenuation, low-frequency operation is often favored for underwater antennas for communication over larger distances. Lower frequencies, such as ELF (Extremely Low Frequency) and VLF (Very Low Frequency), enable longer propagation distances and improved signal penetration through water. These frequency bands have been successfully used in various underwater communication systems, especially for long-range applications.

• Dipole Antennas: Underwater antennas commonly utilize dipole designs that can offer omnidirectional radiation patterns. Magnetic loop antennas, conversely, are compact and exhibit low sensitivity to the surrounding medium. Depending on the specific application requirements, both antennas can be deployed in different configurations, such as towed, fixed, or moored setups.

• Directional Beamforming: Directional beamforming techniques are employed when targeted communication or sensing is required. Arrays of antennas are used to create steerable beams, enhancing the directivity and gain of the system. Beamforming improves signal strength, range, and interference rejection, facilitating reliable communication over extended distances. The design and optimization of such systems require precise modeling and calibration.

•  Hybrid Electromagnetic-Acoustic Systems: Underwater communication systems often integrate electromagnetic and acoustic techniques to overcome the limitations of each modality. Acoustic waves can propagate efficiently over long distances in water, albeit with limited bandwidth. By combining electromagnetic and acoustic communication, hybrid systems offer the potential for improved data rates and coverage in underwater applications.

• Antenna Encapsulation and Protection: Underwater antennas must be adequately protected against harsh environmental conditions, including high hydrostatic pressure, corrosion, and biofouling. Encapsulation techniques, such as potting or conformal coating, provide mechanical protection and enhance resistance to water ingress. Specialized materials and coatings are utilized to mitigate corrosion and minimize the impact of biofouling on antenna performance, ensuring long-term reliability.

• Modeling and Simulation: Advanced electromagnetic modeling and simulation tools are indispensable for designing and optimizing underwater antennas. Finite Element Method (FEM) simulations and numerical analysis aid in assessing antenna performance, including impedance matching, radiation patterns, and efficiency. These tools allow designers to explore various antenna configurations, optimizing design parameters to achieve the desired performance characteristics.

Electromagnetic Properties in Water

Conductivity refers to the ability of a material to conduct electric current. In the case of water, conductivity arises from the presence of dissolved ions and other charged particles. These ions enable the flow of electric current through the water. The conductivity of water is proportional to factors such as temperature, salinity, and the concentration of dissolved substances. Seawater, for example, acts as a partially conducting medium, resulting in higher conductivity. For this reason, special care must be accounted for in antenna designs for underwater seawater applications. Furthermore, unless the body of water is completely deionized, most other underwater water applications will also have a nonzero conductivity that may need to be considered. 

Permittivity, denoted by the symbol ε, measures a material's ability to store electrical energy in the presence of an electric field. In the context of water, permittivity plays a significant role in determining the speed and behavior of electromagnetic waves as they pass through the medium. When an electromagnetic wave propagates through water, the high permittivity of the medium leads to increased interaction between the wave and the water molecules. 

Seawater possesses a high relative dielectric permittivity (for example, an ε_r=81 at 20°C and 1 GHz frequency). This high permittivity of course also varies with frequency and increases with salinity and temperature. The relative permittivity (εr), vacuum permittivity (εo = 8.85 × 10⁻¹² F/m), conductivity (σ), and angular frequency (ω) determine the permittivity of water, which can be calculated using the equation below: 

However, the propagation of an EM wave in the +X direction, with an electric field oscillation in the E_y direction in a saltwater medium, the propagation is dictated by the equation

Where gamma squared is defined as 

But since saltwater is a strong conducting medium, σ≫ωε_water, and so the propagation depth is limited primarily not due to the permittivity, but the conductivity of the solution. Therefore, gamma can be simplified to 

Where μ is the magnetic permeability of the underwater medium —close to that of free air. In other words, underwater applications have a similar magnetic permeability to free air, and therefore the magnetic component of the EM wave is not as affected as the electric component.

Consequently, freshwater has a lower attenuation of electromagnetic waves, allowing for improved signal propagation over longer distances. The lower permittivity of freshwater also leads to less dispersion and distortion of the transmitted signals.

Antenna design for underwater applications is a very specific yet multidimensional field that must  address the unique challenges of the underwater environment. Continued research and innovation in this field hold great potential for enabling new advancements and discoveries in underwater applications. To overcome the challenges of designing antennas for underwater applications, it is crucial to leverage advanced tools that enable accurate modeling and optimization. Cadence AWR Software provides the cutting-edge capabilities needed to tackle the complexities of underwater antenna design. With its powerful electromagnetic simulation tools, such as Finite Element Method (FEM) simulations and numerical analysis, you can assess antenna performance, including impedance matching, radiation patterns, and efficiency. 

Leading electronics providers rely on Cadence products to optimize power, space, and energy needs for a wide variety of market applications. To learn more about our innovative solutions, talk to our team of experts or subscribe to our YouTube channel.